Think tank SecondStreet.org responded today to recent false claims about changes to Alberta’s health care system, changes which will bring it closer to European models. SecondStreet.org has travelled to Sweden, France and Japan to learn firsthand about how their public systems deliver care much faster.
“There’s a lot to criticize about Alberta’s health care system and every other province’s system in Canada for that matter, but the changes we’re seeing in Alberta will bring it closer to universal public systems in Europe where they have shorter wait times,” said SecondStreet.org President Colin Craig. “When we travelled to Sweden, France and Japan to see their systems firsthand and talk with their officials they were shocked by wait times in Canada.”
Americanization or Europeanization?
| U.S.A | Alberta | Europe | |
| Universal Public System | NO | YES | YES |
| Private Options | YES | YES (Coming Soon) | YES |
Sweden – Almost all patients use their public system, but about 13% choose to purchase private health insurance. Those who purchase private insurance take pressure off their public system. To see a video about their system or to learn more – click here
France – The French public system also covers everyone and almost all workers also purchase private insurance. French patients can choose between government, non-profit and for-profit hospitals for treatment. To see a video about their system or to learn more – click here
Japan – Everyone is covered by their public system, a healthy market of government, non-profit and for-profit clinics and hospitals deliver surgery promptly. To see a video about their system or to learn more – click here
Data from the Commonwealth Fund and Fraser Institute show that Canadians were most likely to wait more than two months for elective surgery and more than one month to see a specialist compared with European nations.
Guardrails to Protect the Public:
The Alberta government has committed to put in place guardrails to ensure staff do not all switch to non-government providers. This is consistent with Germany, France and others that have similar protections. In Germany, dual-practice physicians must commit to working at least 25 hours for the public system before they can provide private care. In France, the requirement
is five “half-days” and private activity is capped at 20% of physicians’ public activity. This will mean that instead of flying to other provinces or other countries to make some extra money on the side, Alberta surgeons will be able to do so right in Alberta.
To read more about how countries with dual-practice protect the public system click here to see a blog post with more information.
“To be frank, if someone calls the changes happening in Alberta “Americanization” or that we’re not moving closer to European models, it’s clear they either don’t know what they’re talking about or they’re simply trying to fearmonger,” added Craig. “Either way it’s disappointing.”